VOICES FROM THE INTERNET
========================

Opinions on Software Patents
----------------------------

    The League for Programming Freedom

On Sunday night, while the League for Programming Freedom was
preparing its testimony for this hearing, it was decided to
electronically send a form to some of its members on the Internet,
allowing them to have a say in what the League's testimony should be.

Some of our members then decided to forward this note to other
bulletin boards and mailing lists not affiliated with the League,
significantly increasing the number of responses we received.

To date we have received 280 responses from the Internet community.
The following document provides edited highlights. We feel these
responses provide an accurate reflection of some of the concerns of
the software development community.










Most respondents included phone numbers and electronic mail addresses
from which it should be possible to obtain further information.
From jim@kaos.stanford.edu  Sun Jan 23 23:57:32 1994
Received: from life.ai.mit.edu by geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu (5.65/4.0) with SMTP
	id <AA21213@geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu>; Sun, 23 Jan 94 23:57:32 -0500
Received: from lamour (bauhaus.Stanford.EDU) by life.ai.mit.edu (4.1/AI-4.10) for lpf-pto-letters-archive@gnu.ai.mit.edu id AA23243; Sun, 23 Jan 94 23:57:14 EST
Received: from [127.0.0.1] by lamour (4.1/inc-1.0)
	id AA06903; Sun, 23 Jan 94 20:58:54 PST
Message-Id: <9401240458.AA06903@lamour>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
In-Reply-To: Your message of "Sun, 23 Jan 94 12:17:31 EST."
             <9401231717.AA04303@apple-gunkies.gnu.ai.mit.edu> 
Date: Sun, 23 Jan 94 20:58:52 -0800
From: jim@kaos.stanford.edu


  Name     : James Helman                     Email : jimh@sgi.com
  Title    : Member Tech Staff                Phone : 415.591.8165
  Employer : Silicon Graphics
  
  Companies and Individuals
  -------------------------
  
  Check all that apply:
  
      _X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.
  
      _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.
  
      _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.
  
      _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.
  
      _X_  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
           applied to other industries.
  
      _X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:
  
              __ 1 year     __ 2 years    __ 3 years
              _X_ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :
  
  Additional comments:
  
      A couple years ago, I was involved with a start up that was shot
      down by a bogus software patent.  We were well on our way to having
      several hundred thousand dollars of private placement venture
      capital.  Out of the blue, another company was awarded an extremely
      broad software systems patent for an obvious concept with
      substantial existing prior art.  We received a cease and desist
      letter, and our funding evaporated.  The sad thing is that the
      company that received the patent was so incompetent that they went
      out of business shortly afterwards.

      Business success should be determined by who has the best ideas, best
      implementations, and best marketing.  Some proponents of patents
      claim that patents help protect ideas of small companies from being
      appropriated by large companies.  In my experience, when small
      companies compete successfully against larger ones it is more often
      due to the small company being more focused and  nimble, than from
      patent-protected intellectual property.

      I'm not totally opposed to patents of software.  In my opinion, the
      best solution would be a dramatic increase in the novelty standard
      required for a patent to be awarded along with a reduction in term.
      If the invention is truly something that other researchers or
      developers would not come upon for a decade, some protection and
      reward is reasonable in exchange for the inventor's contribution.
      However, this standard would rule out virtually all current
      software patents, and is sufficiently unlikely to be applied, that
      I favor outright abolition of software patents.  While non-optimum,
      this would at least be a substantial improvement over the current
      situation which is stifling to small companies and those who would
      start them.










Date: Sun, 23 Jan 1994 21:13:18 -0500
From: "Geoffrey S. Knauth" <gsk@marble.com>
Message-Id: <199401240213.AA22371@carrara.bos.marble.com>
Received: by istrian.bos.marble.com.marble.com (4.1/SMI-4.1)
	id AA01797; Sun, 23 Jan 94 21:13:16 EST

Name of Company     : Marble Associates     Contact Person : Geoffrey Knauth
Annual Revenue      : private               Email          : gsk@marble.com
Number of Employees : 40                    Phone          : 617/891-5555

    Marble Associates is a 10-year old company specializing in
    technology consulting that currently employs 40 people.  A
    significant number of Marble programmers is concerned about the
    threat that software patents pose to the software industry, and
    they believe software patents should be granted for a period of no
    more than 1 year.  Marble Associates itself, however, has not
    expressed its opinion on the matter.

Geoffrey










Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 01:20 PST
From: adam@adam.yggdrasil.com (Adam J. Richter)
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company : Yggdrasil Computing, Inc. Contact Person : Adam J. Richter
Annual Revenue      : $1 million (est. '94) Email          : adam@yggdrasil.com
Number of Employees : 3                     Phone          : 408 261-6630

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    The duration of intellectual property restrictions should be
    shortened to reflect the change in the lengths of product
    cycles between Elizebethan England and today.

    I have yet to see anything that was developed as a result of
    patent incentives in software.  On the other hand, I regularly
    hear about numerous software patents that could destroy our
    company.

    Adam J. Richter
    President
    Yggdrasil Computing, Inc.









From: Chris Caputo <ccaputo@microsoft.com>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
Date: Sun, 23 Jan 94 19:04:06 PST

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Chris Caputo                     Email : ccaputo@microsoft.com
Title    : Software Design Engineer         Phone : 206-936-2519
Employer : Microsoft Corporation

    _x_  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    As a budding entrepreneur, I have little hope of starting
    a software business in the present environment.  Existing
    companies are too hostile with their patents.  I would
    be unable to survive a litigious attack from a large software
    company.  Software patents are deterring myself and others
    from starting businesses.  Instead, I must work for a large
    company such as Microsoft.  Why?  Because only large companies
    can afford to defend themselves in a patent suit.

    In addition, companies such as Microsoft, are forced to apply
    for patents they normally wouldn't bother with, simply because
    these patents can be used as a defense mechanism against other
    companies wielding software patents.










Date: 24 Jan 1994 08:09:35 -0500 (EST)
From: bruc@horta.bms.com (Robert Bruccoleri)
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Robert E. Bruccoleri             Email :  bruc@bms.com
Title    : Principal Scientist              Phone : 609 252-6165
Employer : Bristol-Myers Squibb Company

    XX  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    I believe that the software industry has grown rapidly
    because patents have not been available. Ideas and algorithms
    have spread very quickly as a result, and given the low
    production costs for software, it has allowed thousands of
    businesses to start and prosper. Software patents will raise
    the costs of doing business significantly, and will destroy
    the incentive for small software businesses to start. In
    addition, patent royalties will eventually squeeze the
    profits of the big players, thereby causing a catastrophe at
    both ends of the economic spectrum.










From: adelman@tgv.com (Kenneth Adelman)
Reply-To: Adelman@tgv.com (Kenneth Adelman)
Message-Id: <940124075649.6080023c@TGV.COM>

> To be Filed out by Companies Only
> ---------------------------------

> Name of Company     :  TGV, Inc.	      Contact Person : Kenneth Adelman
> Annual Revenue      :  $18M		      Email	     : Adelman@TGV.COM
> Number of Employees :  58		      Phone	     : 408 457 5200


>     XX  Favor making software non-patentable.


TGV is a 5 year old company employing 50+ people with an annual
revenue of over $20M.  TGV specializes in providing network
connectivity software and is concerned about the threat that
software patents pose to the software industry.  As an example,
the UNISYS software patent on LZ-compression was sufficiently
disconcerting, given the current state of software patents, to
cause us to remove a data compression feature in one of our
products.   TGV advocates that software related inventions
be non-patentable.

David Kashtan
CEO TGV Incorporated










From williams@bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov  Tue Jan 25 16:49:18 1994
Received: from life.ai.mit.edu by geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu (5.65/4.0) with SMTP
	id <AA20954@geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu>; Tue, 25 Jan 94 16:49:18 -0500
Received: from bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov by life.ai.mit.edu (4.1/AI-4.10) for lpf-pto-letters-archive@gnu.ai.mit.edu id AA02201; Tue, 25 Jan 94 16:48:45 EST
Received: from localhost (localhost [127.0.0.1]) by bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov (8.6.4/8.6.4) with SMTP id QAA15157 for lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu; Tue, 25 Jan 1994 16:48:44 -0500
Message-Id: <199401252148.QAA15157@bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov>
X-Authentication-Warning: bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov: Host localhost didn't use HELO protocol

    To be Filed out by Individuals Only
    -----------------------------------
    
    Name     : James W. Williams          Email : willams@bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov
    Title    : Principal Systems Programmer   Phone : +1 301 286-1131
    Employer : Hughes STX Corporation
    
        XXX  Favor making software non-patentable.

    Additional comments:
    
	I consider the trouble being caused by software patents to be
	the greatest single threat to the American software industry
	today.  Far more threatening than foreign competition, the American
	software industry is headed for self destruction from all the
	non-productive legal machinations surrounding software patents
	and user interface copyrights.

	As a compromise position, I would tentatively favor changing the
	patent laws such that software patents must be published before
	being granted, to permit prior-art to be submitted before the
	patent is granted.  This is particularly important in a field as
	new and volatile as computer software.

    








From agleckle@us.oracle.com  Mon Jan 24 12:32:58 1994
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 09:32:34 PST
From: Arthur Gleckler <agleckle@us.oracle.com>

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Arthur A. Gleckler               Email : agleckle@us.oracle.com
Title    : technical staff                  Phone : (415) 506-2898
Employer : Oracle Corp.

    ++  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    ++  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    ++  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    If software must be patentable, then I do favor restricting_
    software patents in every way possible.

    I am proud that my company has gone on record as being against
    software patents.










From: bill@camco1.celestial.com (Bill Campbell)
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 10:30:41 -0800 (PST)
Reply-To: bill@celestial.com
Organization: Celestial Software, Mercer Island, WA 98040

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     : Celestial Software    Contact Person : Bill Campbell
Annual Revenue      : 150,000               Email          : bill@celestial.com
Number of Employees : 2                     Phone          : (206) 236-1676

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    __ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other : 0 years

Additional comments:

    Software patents appear to be issued by people who have little
	or no experience in programming or software design, thus they
	issue patents on programs/techniques that either have been in
	common use for years, or would be obvious to any competent
	programmer.

Bill
--
INTERNET:  bill@Celestial.COM   Bill Campbell; Celestial Software
UUCP:              camco!bill   8545 SE 68th Street
FAX:           (206) 232-9186   Mercer Island, WA 98040; (206) 947-5591









From unbob@popj1.zko.dec.com  Mon Jan 24 13:47:51 1994
Received: from life.ai.mit.edu by geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu (5.65/4.0) with SMTP
	id <AA28288@geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu>; Mon, 24 Jan 94 13:47:51 -0500
Received: from inet-gw-1.pa.dec.com by life.ai.mit.edu (4.1/AI-4.10) for lpf-pto-letters-archive@gnu.ai.mit.edu id AA19659; Mon, 24 Jan 94 13:47:12 EST
Received: from peano.zk3.dec.com by inet-gw-1.pa.dec.com (5.65/13Jan94)
	id AA25552; Mon, 24 Jan 94 10:44:51 -0800
Received: from popj1.zko.dec.com (popj1.zko.dec.com [16.32.0.137]) by peano.zk3.dec.com (8.6.4+sb/8.6.4+dnet) with SMTP id NAA00749 for <lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu>; Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:41:47 -0500
Received: by popj1.zko.dec.com (5.65/fma-100391);
	id AA01329; Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:42:55 -0500
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:42:55 -0500
From: unbob@popj1.zko.dec.com (Robert Praetorius)

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Robert Praetorius                Email : Praetorius@PopJ1.ZKO.DEC.Com
Title    : Senior Software Engineer         Phone : (603) 881-1808
Employer : Digital Equipment Corporation

     /
    V_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.
     /
    V_  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    After more than a decade and a half in the computer industry
    I fail to see evidence that software patents have significantly
    (or even perceptibly) increased competition and innovation.
    Abuse of the system, in the form  of patenting techniques that
    are common practice, appears to be extensive and injures regard
    for the law.  If software patents and look-and-feel copyrights
    are to be preserved (and I sincerely hope the aren't) they
    should at least be subject to higher standards.










Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 10:57:16 +0800
From: jwm@mojave.kaleida.com (Jeff McCarrell)

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Jeff McCarrell                   Email : jwm@kaleida.com
Title    : Sr. Programmer                   Phone : 415) 966-0460
Employer : Kaleida Labs, Inc.

    XX  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    XX  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    XX  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    In my 12 years of experience in the software industry, my
    experience with software patents has been mostly negative.
    Under the current system, the small software startups that
    I have been involved with typically try to obtain patents
    as a defensive posture.  Small software companies fear 
    the nuisance suits for violation of software patents that 
    larger firms can bring.  One vice president of engineering
    told me the idea was if they brought a patent violation
    suit, then you brought one and since these patents tend to
    be so broad, the two cases essentially cancel each other.
    This defensive capability was the primary motivation for
    the one patent application I have been personally involved
    in.










From: CDH@GNU.AI.MIT.EDU@INTERNET#
INTERNET# Document Id: <9401231717.AA04303@apple-gunkies.gnu.ai
 
Item    5732207                 94/01/23        09:17
 
From:   CDH@GNU.AI.MIT.EDU@INTERNET#    Gateway to Internet/BITNET/UUCP
 
To:     SHAYER                          Sentient SW, David Shayer,PRT
  
To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------
 
Name of Company     : Sentient Software     Contact Person : David Shayer
Annual Revenue      : $500K        Email          : shayer@applelink.apple.com
Number of Employees : 5                     Phone          : (415) 595-2523
 
Companies and Individuals
-------------------------
 
Check all that apply:
 
    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.
 
    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.
 
    _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.
  
    _X_  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
        applied to other industries.









From nerd@percy.rain.com  Mon Jan 24 14:37:57 1994

Name     : Michael N Galassi                Email : mng@clam.com
Title    : Sr Consulting Engineer           Phone : 503 531 3370
Employer : CLAM Associates

    I feel companies that invest in research deserve protection
    for their work but in an industry where time moves a the pace
    it does in ours a diferent standard is needed.  One year feels
    right to me but may not to others, I'm do feel certain that the
    current standard is way too long.









From csmith@mozart.convex.com  Mon Jan 24 14:11:09 1994
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:08:28 -0600
From: csmith@mozart.convex.com (Chris Smith)
Message-Id: <199401241908.NAA08491@mozart.convex.com>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
In-Reply-To: Chris Hofstader's message of Sun, 23 Jan 94 12:17:31 -0500 

   To be Filed out by Individuals Only
   -----------------------------------

   Name     : Chris Smith                      Email : csmith@convex.com
   Title    : Sr Development Engineer          Phone : 214 497-4504
   Employer : Convex Computer Corporation

   Companies and Individuals
   -------------------------

   Check all that apply:

      _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

      _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

      _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

   Additional comments:

Ask almost any practitioner in the (flourishing) software industry whether
software patents advance or retard progress in this useful art.  In my 
experience there is almost a consensus that software patents are not
helpful but quite harmful.  The present scheme, if implemented seriously,
would bring progress to a standstill almost instantly.

The main reason people around here sweat patents at all is to form
cross-licensing agreements, thus nullifying the whole nuisance, one tiny
piece at a time.

Good copyright protection is essential, and sufficient.










From mike@pooh.tec.army.mil  Mon Jan 24 15:25:06 1994
Received: by pooh.tec.army.mil (4.1/SMI-4.1)
	id AA11365; Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:24:19 EST
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:24:19 EST
From: mike@pooh.tec.army.mil (Mike McDonnell)

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     :  Michael M. McDonnell            Email : mike@tec.army.mil
Title    :  Physicist                       Phone : (703)922-5698
Employer :  U.S. Army Engineers Topographic Engineering Center

    Patents will slow down software development and penalize the 
    Government in its procurement.  Penalties would be in the form
    of both cost and time.  For the military, developing timely
    systems is crucial to maintaining our technical superiority
    in battle, so it is in the interest of national security to
    not have software patents.










From billw@riverside.scrc.symbolics.com  Mon Jan 24 15:25:50 1994
Received: from life.ai.mit.edu by geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu (5.65/4.0) with SMTP
	id <AA00291@geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu>; Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:25:50 -0500
Received: from RIVERSIDE.SCRC.Symbolics.COM by life.ai.mit.edu (4.1/AI-4.10) for lpf-pto-letters-archive@gnu.ai.mit.edu id AA25736; Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:25:28 EST
Received: from WINTER-PARK.sdc.symbolics.com ([128.81.253.105]) by RIVERSIDE.SCRC.Symbolics.COM via INTERNET with SMTP id 1091185; 24 Jan 1994 13:03:55 -0500
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:02-0500
From: Bill Wilkinson <billw@riverside.scrc.symbolics.com>

    To be Filed out by Individuals Only
    -----------------------------------

    Name     : Bill Wilkinson                   Email : billw@symbolics.com
    Title    : Sales Support Engineer           Phone : 703-876-0243
    Employer : Symbolics, Inc.

	XX  Favor making software non-patentable.

    Additional comments:

	Copyright law provides all of the intellectual property law
needed for software and the software industry.









From bostic@vangogh.cs.berkeley.edu  Mon Jan 24 15:35:41 1994
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 15:33:13 -0500
From: bostic@vangogh.cs.berkeley.edu (Keith Bostic)
Message-Id: <199401242033.PAA03054@python.bostic.com>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
Subject: Re: YOUR OPINION ON SOFTWARE PATENTS

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Keith Bostic                     Email : bostic@cs.berkeley.edu
Title    : Programmer/Analyst III           Phone : 508-287-4781
Employer : University of California, Berkeley

Check all that apply:

   Yes  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

   Yes  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

   Yes  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    No  Favor making software non-patentable.

   Yes  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

           Yes 1 year    Yes 2 years   Yes 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    I strongly believe that the current situation with respect
    to software patents is fatally flawed.  I don't pretend
    to believe that I know the solution, however, I am becoming
    increasingly aware that fundamental ideas which should be
    usable by others are being locked down by companies.  This
    does NOT encourage innovation, it circumscribes it to less
    fruitful areas because companies can (and, in my experience,
    do!) use the legal system to maintain a monopoly on ideas
    as well as to drive small entrepreneurs out of business.

    More specifically, MANY of the patents that I have seen
    granted are trivial in the extreme, and it is laughable that
    anyone could possibly consider the ideas either original
    or other than the most obvious extensions of previous work.

    Finally, providing protection for more than three years, in
    an industry that completely reinvents itself every five years,
    is again, laughable, and only encourages companies to excel
    in litigation.










From curtis@ans.net  Mon Jan 24 15:38:21 1994
  (InterLock SMTP Gateway 1.1 for lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu);
  Mon, 24 Jan 1994 15:37:58 -0500
Received: by interlock.ans.net (Internal Mail Agent-2);
  Mon, 24 Jan 1994 15:37:58 -0500
Received: by interlock.ans.net (Internal Mail Agent-1);
  Mon, 24 Jan 1994 15:37:58 -0500
From: Curtis Villamizar <curtis@ans.net>
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:36:59 -0500

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Curtis Villamizar                Email : curtis@ans.net
Title    : Sr Enginner                      Phone : 914-789-5309
Employer : Advanced Network and Services


    Stardization of sofware platforms has a tremendous positive
    effect on the productivity of the US software industry and
    progress of the field of computer science.  The underlying basic
    tools do not have to be reinvented with each application.
    Software patents serve to undermine this.  There is already very
    strong motivation to develope new software techniques and very
    strong activity in this area.  The intent of the patent system
    simply does not apply to the computer software industry.
    Software patents have so far only served as attempts to restrain
    competition or by opportunists as attempts to erect artificial
    barriers by restriciting use of obvious techniques and then draw
    revenue from those barriers.  The software industry would
    greatly benefit by the total exclusion of software from the
    patent process.










From margo@das.harvard.edu  Mon Jan 24 15:38:03 1994
Received: from life.ai.mit.edu by geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu (5.65/4.0) with SMTP
	id <AA00520@geech.gnu.ai.mit.edu>; Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:38:03 -0500
Received: from virtual61.harvard.edu by life.ai.mit.edu (4.1/AI-4.10) for lpf-pto-letters-archive@gnu.ai.mit.edu id AA26890; Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:37:55 EST
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 15:37:43 EST
From: margo@das.harvard.edu
Message-Id: <9401242037.AA03841@virtual61.harvard.edu>

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     :Margo Seltzer                     Email :margo@das.harvard.edu
Title    :Assistant Professor               Phone :617-496-5663
Employer :Harvard University

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     X_ 2 years    __ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    Software patents, as they are currently being applied, are
    a menace to the software industry.  Patents benefit the
    large corporations that can use patents as bargaining chips
    while severly penalizing small companies.

    At an absolute minimum, the requirements for the Patent
    Bar must be broadened to allow (and encourage) software
    professionals to become patent agents.










Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 16:07:04 -0500
From: chris@das.harvard.edu

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Christopher Small                Email : chris@das.harvard.edu
Title    : Research Assistant               Phone : 617-495-5866
Employer : Harvard University

Companies and Individuals
-------------------------

Check all that apply:

    xx  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    xx  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    xx  Favor making software non-patentable.

    xx  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
        applied to other industries.

    xx  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     xx 2 years    __ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    As an engineer with substantial industry experience, both at
    large companies (e.g. Microsoft, AT&T Bell Labs) and several small,
    entrepeneurial companies doing leading-edge product development,
    I feel strongly that software patents seriously limit the 
    competitiveness of software developers. The Patent Office should take 
    special care to ensure the novelty of software before granting a 
    patent on it, and, in my opinion, never grant a patent on software. 










Date: Mon, 24 Jan 1994 13:05:37 -0800
From: Mohsen Banan <mohsen@rostam.neda.com>
Message-Id: <199401242105.AA07756@rostam.neda.com>
To: comments-software@uspto.gov
Cc: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     :   Tele-Voice          Contact Person : Mohsen Banan
Annual Revenue      :   350K                Email          : mohsen@neda.com
Number of Employees :   1                   Phone          : +1 (206) 644-8026

    XX  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
        applied to other industries.

    XX  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    XX 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    Existing laws regarding Intelectual Property Rights are 
    outdated. These laws are doing more harm to the public's
    interest and our software industry's interest than good.
    Usefull and exciting technolgy is not being deployed or 
    used because of serious flaws in our laws. Examples of such
    technology are Public Key Cryptography Systems and Man-Machine
    interfaces.

    The orderly transition of our society from "manufacturing" to
    "information processing" hinges on vision and wisdom of our public
    sector. Time is of essence.  Re-evaluation of our 
    Intelectual Property laws is urgently needed.










From: eggert@twinsun.com (Paul Eggert)
Message-Id: <9401250106.AA00496@bi.twinsun.com>
Date: 25 Jan 1994 10:06:04 +0900

YOUR OPINION ON SOFTWARE PATENTS
================================

Information you provide will be forwarded to the patent office.

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     : Twin Sun, Inc         Contact Person : Paul Eggert
Annual Revenue      : not public info       Email          : eggert@twinsun.com
Number of Employees : 15                    Phone          : +1 310 524 1800

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Paul Eggert                      Email : eggert@twinsun.com
Title    : Director, R&D                    Phone : +1 310 524 1800
Employer : Twin Sun, Inc

Companies and Individuals
-------------------------

Check all that apply:

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    __  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
	applied to other industries.

    X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

	    __ 1 year     X_ 2 years    __ 3 years
	    __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

I do not support a ``higher standard of novelty for software than that
applied to other industries'', but I do support a higher standard of
novelty than the USPTO seems to be applying to software patents.  In
my opinion, the current standard for software novelty is much lower
than that for other industries.










From disab@autodesk.com  Mon Jan 24 21:49:08 1994
Date: Mon, 24 Jan 94 18:28:18 PST
From: disab@autodesk.com (Dave DiSabatino)
Message-Id: <9401250228.AA21215@ogma.autodesk.com>

} To be Filed out by Individuals Only
} -----------------------------------
} 
} Name     : E. David DiSabatino            Email : disab@autodesk.com
} Title    : Senior Programmer                        
} Employer : Autodesk, INC
} 
} Companies and Individuals
} -------------------------
} 
} Check all that apply:
} 
}     _x_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.
} 
}     _x_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.
} 
}     _x_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.
} 
}     _x_  Favor making software non-patentable.
}
} Additional comments:

Those who follow the software industry have clearly seen the damage
done to users and developers alike by software patents. Software
patents set back the state of the industry in general.  They make
competition impossible and make the users lose.

Patents were designed to protect ideas.  In manufacturing ideas are
valuable because manufacturing is cheap.  In software ideas are cheap
but implementation is difficult.  There is no shortage of good ideas,
but once someone has come up with an idea, it takes a team of experts,
not an easy group to assemble, to actually take that idea to fruition.
VPLs patent of the data glove has probably set back the virtual reality
industry by several years.  Apple's patent of their interface has made
everyone suffer.  The implementation of software should be protected,
and can be, with a copyright on the actual code.  If someone were to
steal sections of code, this would be stealing a protected comodity.
Stealing someone's idea should be considered a compliment not a crime.

Removing or shortening software patents, or making them only apply
to particular implementations of an idea will inevitable increase
competition and help the software industry in general.  Until we
come up with software components that can be assembled as easily
as blocks of lego, software patents will hurt the industry, because
only an entire system is worth money.










From tim@ora.com  Tue Jan 25 00:12:05 1994

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     :O'Reilly & Associates, Inc.  Contact Person : Tim O'Reilly
Annual Revenue      : 13 million (1993)                    Email : tim@ora.com
Number of Employees : 95                        Phone  707-829-0515        :

    _x_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    _x_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    _x_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    __  Favor making software non-patentable.

    _x_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    _x_ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    1.  I don't come out above as totally against software patents
    because I can imagine some kind of invention that is so totally
    original that someone ought to have some chance to exploit it
    even if they aren't a big player--as software becomes more
    monopolistic, with companies like Microsoft in the driver's seat,
    patents may serve the public good at some point by allowing
    smaller players to have a bit more of a level playing field.
    For that reason, the idea of a short protection period for
    highly original ideas might not be a bad alternative.  But
    the patent office needs to be very highly trained to recognize
    not only originality but also non-obviousness.  The number of
    software "patents" that really recognize obvious or nearly
    inevitable developments is far too large.  One possible criterion
    might be to say that if more than two people independently come
    up with the same technique, that it is not patentable.

    2, It should not be possible to get a private patent for the
    results of government funded research.  What's more, there
    should be very tight restrictions on the ability of publically
    funded institutions to claim that *any* of their activities
    were privately funded and thus deserving of patent protection,
    since it is too easy to move things from one side of the house
    to the other.

    3. Public key cryptography should be in the public domain!  The
patents assigned to Public Key Partners are one of the single largest
obstacles to the progress of the "information superhighway" our
government supposedly wishes to see put into place.

-- 
Tim O'Reilly @ O'Reilly & Associates, Inc.  Publishers of Nutshell Handbooks
103 Morris Street, Sebastopol, CA 95472   To reach me: 707-829-3382
To order:  707-829-0515, 800-998-9938, FAX 707-829-0104  
Internet:  tim@ora.com     UUCP:  uunet!ora.com!tim









From kingdon@cygnus.com  Tue Jan 25 10:17:07 1994
From: kingdon@cygnus.com (Jim Kingdon)
Message-Id: <9401251516.AA09529@cygnus.com>
Received: by lioth.cygnus.com (4.1/SMI-4.1)
	id AA00162; Tue, 25 Jan 94 10:16:24 EST

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     :  James Kingdon                  Email : kingdon@cygnus.com
Title    :  Programmer                      Phone : 703 894 5580
Employer :  Cygnus Support


Additional comments:

    The software industry has/had no problems which software
    patents have solved or could solve.









From ezaust@math.sunysb.edu  Tue Jan 25 09:53:19 1994
From: ezaust@math.sunysb.edu (Eugene Zaustinsky)
Message-Id: <9401251452.AA28385@math.sunysb.edu>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
Subject: comments for pto

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Dr. Eugene Zaustinsky            Email : ezaust@math.sunysb.edu
Title    : Professor of Mathematics         Phone : (516) 757-4402
Employer : State University of New York at Stony Brook

    XX  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    XX  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    XX  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    The fundamental purpose of all copyright and patent law is
    to advance the public interest by encouraging innovation.
    The innovator is granted the limited exclusive right to 
    commercially exploit his innovation for a limited time, in 
    exchange for the early disclosure of the essence of his 
    innovation.  It is important to understand that the courts 
    have always held that the government has no interest in 
    advancing the fortunes of innovators.

    In writing a piece of software, the programmer draws on an enormous
    body of existing knowledge. He selects existing pieces of knowledge 
    (code fragments, procedures, algorithms, and so on) and puts them 
    together, in what is generally a perfectly straightforward way,
    to do something useful. Once in a while he discovers or invents 
    a new piece of knowledge but, in my opinion, this is the exception 
    rather than the rule. The process is pretty much like writing 
    anything else.  What the programmer can actually write is strongly 
    constrained, in pretty much the same way that what an author can
    actually write is strongly constrained by the rules of grammar, 
    syntax, and so on. Consequently, the result of programming effort
    should be protected in pretty much the same way that other written 
    work is protected. In particular, if the author of a book invents 
    a new word or turn of phrase, he cannot patent it. Similarly, if
    a programmer devises a new code fragment or algorithm, he should
    also not be able to patent it.

    A piece of software should be protected from outright copying
    by copyright law, just like a book. In asking for further 
    protection, however, it is my opinion that software vendors are 
    asking the government to advance their fortunes, without regard 
    for the fundamental purposes of patent and copyright law, without 
    regard for the health of their own industry, and without regard 
    for the public interest.









Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 09:55:46 -0500
From: david@elwapo.agricon.com (David C. Brown)
Message-Id: <9401251455.AA24808@elwapo>
To: uunet!WPI.EDU!csa@uunet.uu.net
Cc: david@uunet.uu.net, uunet!prep.ai.mit.edu!lpf-pto-letters@uunet.uu.net,
        uunet!uspto.gov!comments-software@uunet.uu.net

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     : Agricon Int. Inc.     Contact Person : Sherry L.  Tucker
Annual Revenue      :                       Email          : sherry@elwapo.agricon.com
Number of Employees : 5                     Phone          : (813) 275-341124

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : David C. Brown IV                Email : david@elwapo.agricon.com
Title    : Communications Specialist        Phone : (813) 275-3411
Employer : Agricon International Inc.

Companies and Individuals
-------------------------

Check all that apply:

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    __ 3 years
            X_ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

    Due to the rapid change that the computer industry experiences,
    shorter patent terms are in order. The equipment changes by_
    enough generations to give the autors sufficient reward for their
    creativity. However, software patents should still be uncommon
    as copyrights still provide excellent protection. As a patent
    holder myself (#5,133,668) and author of several software items
    (programs and algorithms) both proprietary and public-domain,
    I believe I am speaking from an informed position.








Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 13:28:35 -0500
From: Gerald Jay Sussman <gjs@martigny.ai.mit.edu>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu

To be Filed out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Gerald Jay Sussman
Title    : Matsushita Professor of Electrical Engineering
Employer : Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Email    : gjs@martigny.ai.mit.edu
Phone    : (617) 253-5874

Companies and Individuals
-------------------------

Check all that apply:

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ other : as short as politically possible.

Additional comments:

       I consider software patents to be harmful to all long-run
    interests, including business.  Software patents may very well
    confer short-timescale advantages to patent holders, but the
    overall economic health of industry and the nation depends upon
    continuing innovation and cooperation among innovators, especially
    in an industry where interoperability of components is crucial to
    succes.










From: dan@copernicus.bbn.com (Dan Franklin)

To be Filled out by Individuals Only
-----------------------------------

Name     : Daniel Franklin                  Email : dfranklin@bbn.com
Title    : Sr. Scientist                    Phone : 617-873-3871
Employer : Bolt Beranek & Newman, Inc.

    _?_  Favor making software non-patentable (see comments below).

    _Y_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    _Y_ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

It is clear to me as a software practitioner that the current system for
patenting software is badly broken.  I am not sure that software patents
ought to exist at all, but if they do continue to exist, their nature must
be changed.

First, the useful life of a software invention is hardly ever as long as 17
years, so software patents currently grant an effectively unlimited
monopoly on the use of the patented idea.  The life of software patents
MUST be shortened to no more than 3 years, possibly less, so that it will
be of limited duration, as intended by the Constitution.

Second, the secrecy surrounding software patents in the licensing process
must be eliminated.  It is impractical, to say the least, to try to develop
and market software without knowing whether one about to infringe on a
patent that has not yet been issued.  With the advent of the
"first-to-file" rule it would seem that there is no longer any reason to
keep patent applications secret until they have been granted or rejected. 
Elimination of secrecy would also permit knowledgeable individuals outside
the PTO to provide examples of prior art, or arguments against sufficient
novelty in the patent, before the patent is issued.

Third, if software patent application secrecy is not eliminated (and
probably even if it is), the PTO must use people whose primary, and
potentially only, training is in computer science to examine software
patent applications in order to ensure that obvious ideas are not granted
patent protection.  The time to issue a patent must also be shortened; in
the software world, yesterday's novelty is tomorrow's routine, and it
becomes difficult to distinguish what may have been novel 5 years ago from
what was routine even then.

Fourth, the standard of novelty must be raised.  Any useful piece of
software is so complex that it will, of necessity, contain some novel
collection of parts used to provide some new function; thus virtually any
software seems to be patentable under current rules.  The standard of
novelty must be high enough so that only ideas worth publishing in a
peer-reviewed trade journal (as a minimum) could be granted a patent.  The
Compton's multimedia patent, for example, would clearly fail this test.

The PTO should also consider whether patent protection for software is
simply not useful--that is, if it is not in the public interest.  I suspect
that this may be the case, though the current system is so badly flawed
that it is hard to determine whether one that is truly beneficial could
exist.

        Dan Franklin










From jeffrey@netcom.com  Tue Jan 25 15:19:12 1994
In-Reply-To: Your message of "Sun, 23 Jan 94 12:17:31 EST."
             <9401231717.AA04303@apple-gunkies.gnu.ai.mit.edu> 
Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 12:19:05 -0800
From: Jeffrey Kegler <jeffrey@netcom.com>


> To be Filed out by Companies Only
> ---------------------------------
> 
Name of Company     : Algorists, Inc.       Contact Person : Jeffrey Kegler
Annual Revenue      : not public            Email: jeffrey@netcom.com
Number of Employees : 1                     Phone          : (408) 733-1255

Note: Algorists, Inc. is not publicly held -- it's a very small
consulting firm incorporated in California.  Algorists does not release
financial data except as required by law.

> Companies and Individuals
> -------------------------
> 
> Check all that apply:
> 
    _X  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    _X  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

The items marked with a question mark imply the existence of software
patents.  While admittedly short patent terms are better than long
ones, difficult to obtain patents are better than broad patents for
well known techniques awarded trivially, and the present patent office
procedures aggravate the problem, Algorists, Inc. feels that any
patenting of software will be disastrous for the software industry,
perhaps amounting to the one factor that eliminates the current U.S.
dominance in this field.  Any availability of patents for software
could mean the collapse of our business, we feel.  At the risk of
seeming uncompromising, then, we are thus unable to get excited about
discussing reforms in the process.

Jeffrey Kegler, Independent UNIX Consultant, Algorists, Inc.
jeffrey@algor2.ALGORISTS.COM
137 E Fremont AVE #122, Sunnyvale CA 94087









In-Reply-To: Your message of "Sun, 23 Jan 94 12:17:31 EST."
             <9401231717.AA04303@apple-gunkies.gnu.ai.mit.edu> 
Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 16:48:44 -0500
From: "James W. Williams" <williams@bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov>
X-Mts: smtp

    To be Filed out by Individuals Only
    -----------------------------------
    
    Name     : James W. Williams          Email : willams@bolero.gsfc.nasa.gov
    Title    : Principal Systems Programmer   Phone : +1 301 286-1131
    Employer : Hughes STX Corporation
    
        _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.
    
        XXX  Favor making software non-patentable.
    
    Additional comments:
    
	I consider the trouble being caused by software patents to be
	the greatest single threat to the American software industry
	today.  Far more threatening than foreign competition, the American
	software industry is headed for self destruction from all the
	non-productive legal machinations surrounding software patents
	and user interface copyrights.


	As a compromise position, I would tentatively favor changing the
	patent laws such that software patents must be published before
	being granted, to permit prior-art to be submitted before the
	patent is granted.  This is particularly important in a field as
	new and volatile as computer software.










Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 12:58:42 -0800
From: William Shipley <wjs@omnigroup.com>
Message-Id: <9401252058.AA04061@omnigroup.com>
Received: by NeXT.Mailer (1.99.1)

To be Filled out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     :Omni Development, Inc  Contact Person :Wil Shipley
Annual Revenue      :$500,000               Email          :wjs@omnigroup.com
Number of Employees :9                      Phone          :206-720-2955


Companies and Individuals
-------------------------

Check all that apply:

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    _X_  Support a higher standard of novelty for software than that
         applied to other industries.

    _X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    __ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    _X_ other : NO TERM, NO PATENTS.

Additional comments:

    Small companies like mine are supposedly the embodiment of the "American
    Dream": young entrepeneurs re-inventing how business is done.  With
    software patents, however, the deck is stacked against us.  There is no
    way we can afford to patent what we do, or do an exhaustive patent search
    on every idea we want to use.  Thus, we're constantly putting ourselves
    at risk to get sued and destroyed by some large company that has spent
    its life just sitting around and collecting patents.

    Software patents have recently gotten ridiculous.  We have companies
    claiming they've invented the most basic and obvious ideas, and the
    courts are too ignorant of the software industry to realise these
    claims are spurious.  Compton's Encyclopedia recent claim that they
    own the idea of mulitmedia is so crazy it's laughable, except it isn't a
    joke to the thousands of companies that are now facing making royalty
    payments.  And RSA's patent on encryption algorithms has prevented
    data security from becoming commonplace in America; giving all
    businesses a disadvantage.

    Even patents on ideas that aren't totally obvious are still harmful.  The
    software business changes rapidly; it doesn't take us time to re-tool
    when a new process comes along, unlike in other business.  Software
    patents allow one company to corner a new idea and prevent others from
    improving on it; this hobbles our entire industry.  The whole notion
    of someone "owning" an idea is ludicrous to me; ownership of code is
    fine, but owning an idea is like owning an attitude.









From pothiers@aries.saic.com  Tue Jan 25 16:49:46 1994
Date: Tue, 25 Jan 94 14:43:45 MST
From: pothiers@aries.saic.com (Steve Pothier)
Message-Id: <9401252143.AA07345@aries.saic.com>

   To be Filed out by Individuals Only
   -----------------------------------

   Name     : Steve Pothier                    Email : pothiers@aries.saic.com 
   Title    : Senior Engineer	               Phone : 602-748-7400
   Employer : SAIC

       x_  Favor making software non-patentable.

   Additional comments:

       I have also done consulting work where I created software
       that I believe would be patentable under current law.  I
       refuse to even try because I believe it would contribute
       to the problem.  But, I have tried for a non-software patent.









From: Ken Anderson<anderson@phibro.com>
Site: Phibro Energy Inc (Westport)
Received: by NeXT.Mailer (1.100)
Received: by NeXT Mailer (1.100)
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
Subject: Response form
Reply-To: anderson@biztech.com

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     :  Biztech, Inc.     Contact Person : Ken  Anderson
Annual Revenue      :  $350,000          Email          :  anderson@biztech.com
Number of Employees :  4                 Phone          :  203.328.3711

    x_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    x_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    x_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    x_  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

    Software patents have already affected my business from a
    productivity point of view.  A company called Athena Design
    has removed certain Lotus compatability aspects in fear
    of litigation.  This has directly affected spreadsheets that
    we keep.










From: Vern Blanchard <70760.434@compuserve.com>
To: "INTERNET:friedman@gnu.ai.mit.edu" <friedman@gnu.ai.mit.edu>
Date: 25 Jan 94 14:30:32 EST

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company  :  Advanced Gaming Technology  Contact Person : Vern Blanchard
Annual Revenue     : $1Million                  Email   : 70760,414 (Compuserve)
Number of Employees : 15                        Phone          : (619) 789-2442

    x  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    x  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    x  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    x  Favor making software non-patentable.

Additional comments:

There is virtually NOTHING novel or unique in software programing.  Almost 
any decent programmer can develop any program, given enough time.  There is 
no clear way for  the PTO to check on what is general knowledge in the 
programming community, much less determine if a technique is new.

[LPF editorial comment: Vern Blanchard has recently been in court and
had his business threatened with closure due to a software patent
claiming to cover a form of computerized bingo.]

   








From go_rilla!jon@mtxinu.com  Wed Jan 26 21:42:11 1994
Date:  Wed, 26 Jan 94 18:40:53 -0800
From: go_rilla!jon@mtxinu.com (Jon Hale )
Message-Id:  <9401270240.AA00333@go_rilla.GORILLA.UUCP>
To: lpf-pto-letters@prep.ai.mit.edu
Subject: Software patents

To be Filed out by Companies Only
---------------------------------

Name of Company     :Gorilla Consulting     Contact Person : Jon Hale
Annual Revenue      :                Email          : go_rilla!jon@mtxinu.com
Number of Employees : 1              Phone          : (510) 836-6638


    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to business interests.

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the software industry.

    _X_  Consider software patents harmful to the public interest.

    _X_  Favor making software non-patentable.

    _X_  Support significantly reducing the term for software patents:

            __ 1 year     __ 2 years    __ 3 years
            __ 4 years    __ 5 years    __ other :

Additional comments:

I dislike software patents. I think that they are a very bad influence
on the entire software industry.  If we must have software patents, then I
would favor a very short duration (less than 2 years). 
