6.805 Pre-assignment Question 4

The hypothetical case in Questions 1-3 is mostly real. Beginning in 1990, the police in Florence, Oregon, as well as federal law enforcement officers, began to suspect a man named Sam Shook of growing marijuana. Their investigation eventually turned to his daughter, Tova Shook, who lived in a triplex house. A man named Danny L. Kyllo lived in another unit of the triplex.

In late 1991, Danny Kyllo's ex-wife, Luanne Kyllo, was arrested for possession and delivery of marijuana. Based on this and his proximity to Tova Shook, the police began to suspect that Danny Kyllo was growing marijuana. They obtained his electrical records from the utility company, and concluded (incorrectly, we now know) that his electrical usage was abnormally high. On January 16, 1992, at 3:20 a.m., two law enforcement officers drove by the triplex and recorded the infrared emanation using an infrared video camera -- the "Agema Thermovision 210 thermal imaging device." They saw higher heat from Kyllo's unit of the triplex than from Tova Shook's or from the third unit. The image on the previous page is Kyllo's house, viewed through the Agema 210.

Based on this evidence (the electrical bills, the thermal imaging, and the arrest of his ex-wife, who no longer lived with him), the police obtained a warrant to search Kyllo's house. They found more than one hundred marijuana plants, as well as some weapons and drug paraphernalia. Kyllo was indicted for drug manufacturing a month later.

On May 18, 1992, Kyllo's lawyer moved for the case to be thrown out, because the police had used an infrared camera to "search" his house unreasonably without a warrant. On December 4, 1992, the judge denied the motion, ruling that Kyllo had no reason to expect privacy in the heat emanating from his house. Kyllo pleaded guilty (with the option to appeal) and was sentenced to five years and three months in federal prison.

The case finally reached the Supreme Court of the United States (the most important court in the country) in 2000. On June 11, 2001, the Supreme Court issued a 5-4 decision (five justices in favor, four justices against) in favor of Kyllo, effectively throwing out his conviction and his five-year sentence.

4. Find and read the Supreme Court's June 11, 2001 decision in Kyllo v. United States. (Read both the majority opinion and the four-justice dissent, not just the syllabus. Read the opinions slowly and carefully, but it's okay if you don't understand some of the legal mumbo-jumbo.) Do you still agree with what you wrote in Questions 1 and 2? Would you want to change your answers at all? Why and how? Did the justices bring up any new issues that you found interesting?