The Case of the Bogus Bookseller

1. Read the excerpts from the Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986.

2. Next Thursday, we will have a moot court in 6.805. You will be a prosecutor, a defense attorney, a judge, or an advocate in the criminal case of United States v. David Cook (the Case of the Bogus Bookseller). Read the agreed-upon facts of this fictional case, below.

3. Write five or six sentences on each of the following questions to prepare for the moot court.

  1. Do you think Mr. Cook violated the ECPA? Which parts? Why?
  2. You are the Assistant United States Attorney. Argue that Mr. Cook violated the law.
  3. You are Mr. Cook's attorney. Argue that the case against him should be dismissed.
Email your answers to 6.805-staff@mit.edu before 8 p.m. Wednesday.


Here are the agreed-upon facts of The Case of the Bogus Bookseller:

   Mr. Cook, the defendant, was Vice-president of Interloc,
   Inc. ("Interloc"). Interloc's primary business was as an online
   rare and out-of-print book listing service. As part of its
   services, Interloc provided certain book dealer customers with an
   electronic mail ("e-mail") address and acted as the service
   provider. The dealer was provided with an e-mail account ending in
   "@Interloc.com".

   In May 1998, Alibris, a California corporation, acquired Interloc.
   Defendant was Vice-president, shareholder and employee of Interloc and
   Alibris. Among defendant's responsibilities was the management of the
   Internet Service Provider ("ISP") and the book dealer subscription
   list managed by Interloc.

   The parties stipulated to the following facts relevant to the transfer
   of electronic messages by the Interloc systems. An e-mail message,
   which is composed using an e-mail program, is transferred from one
   computer to another on its way to its final destination, the
   addressee. Building on the principle of store and forward, the message
   is handed to a Message Transfer Agent ("MTA") which stores the message
   locally. The message is routed through the network from one MTA to
   another until it reaches the recipient's mail server, which accepts it
   and stores it in a location accessible to the recipient. Once the
   e-mail is accessible to the recipient, final delivery has been
   completed. The final delivery process places the message into storage
   in a message store area. Often, a separate Mail Delivery Agent ("MDA")
   will be required to retrieve the e-mail from the MTA in order to make
   final delivery.

   Interloc's computer facility used a program known as procmail (short
   for process mail) as its MDA. Procmail operates by scanning and
   sorting e-mail together with an MTA computer program known as
   "sendmail."

   According to the Indictment, on or about January 1998, defendant
   directed Interloc employees to write computer code to intercept and
   copy all incoming communications from Amazon.com to subscriber
   dealers. The Interloc systems administrator wrote a revision to the
   mail processing code called procmail.rc ("the procmail"), designed
   to intercept, copy, and store, all incoming messages from
   Amazon.com before they were delivered to the members' e-mail, and
   therefore, before the e-mail was read by the intended recipient.
   Defendant was charged with using the procmail to intercept
   thousands of messages. Defendant and other Interloc employees
   routinely read the e-mails sent to its members seeking to gain a
   commercial advantage. The procmail was designed to work only
   within the confines of Interloc's computer. At all times that MTA
   sendmail and MDA procmail performed operations affecting the e-mail
   system, the messages existed in the random access memory (RAM) or
   in hard disks, or both, within Interloc's computer systems. Each of
   the e-mails at issue constituted an "electronic communication"
   within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 2510(12).

   Count One of the Indictment charged defendant with conspiracy to
   violate 18 U.S.C. § 2511. Defendant allegedly conspired to
   intercept the electronic communications, to intentionally disclose
   the contents of the intercepted communications, in violation of 18
   U.S.C. § 2511(1)(a), and to use the contents of the unlawfully
   obtained electronic communication, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §
   2511(1)(c). Count Two of the Indictment charged defendant with
   conspiracy to violate 18 U.S.C. § 2701. Defendant allegedly
   conspired to access electronic communications in electronic
   storage, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2701(a).