Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Fall Semester, 2004
MIT 6.805 Project Topics
1. Sensors in public spaces
2. CAPPS II (airline screening) - history and policy analysis
3. MBTA Smart Card Implementation
4. National ID System
5. MIT ID card - privacy and security
Title:
Sensors in public spaces -- Dayton, Superbowl, EZPass, UK
(City of London, RFIDs, etc.)
Description:
Public spaces includes highways, local roads, stadiums,
government office buildings, convenience stores and even
private houses are being built with more and more sensors. The
primary purpose of these sensors vary from collecting tools,
to police surveillance, to crime prevention, and supervision
of child care workers. In some cases, they simply record
images of the areas, while more sophisticated sensors attempt
to track vehicles and even sometimes attempt to identify
individuals through face recognition. Why are these systems
proliferating? What sort of privacy issues do they raise? Are
they effective at their assigned tasks? Are privacy laws up to
dealing with the questions raised by these public sensor
networks? Should there be a "private privacy act" to permit
individuals to see what data is collected about them? Should
government legislate practices for using or collecting this
data? Does it matter whether these sensors are publicly or
privately owned? Do they change people's behavior in either
positive or negative ways?
Bibliography:
Jeffrey Rosen, The Naked Crowd: Reclaiming Security and
Freedom in an Anxious Age, Random House, 2004.
"Sensor Nation" Special Issue, IEEE Spectrum, July 2004.
United States v. Knotts, 460 U.S. 276 (1983) (tracking device
placed in contraband chloroform, with warrantless monitoring).
United States v. McIver, 186 F.3d 1119 (9th Cir. 1999) (unmanned
cameras in national forest, warrantless electronic tracking of
vehicle).
Kyllo v. United States, 533 U.S. 27 (2001) (warrantless
use of thermal imaging device on private house).
John Schwartz, "This Car Can Talk. What It Says May Cause Concern,"
N.Y. Times, Dec. 29, 2003
Jeffrey Selingo, "It's the Cars, Not the Tires, That Squeal,"
N.Y. Times, Oct. 25, 2001
"An Act Relative to Consumer Protection and Radio Frequency
Identification Systems," Draft Bill (Sen. Barrios),
Massachusetts Senate
18 U.S.C. sec. 2710 (2000) ("wrongful disclosure of video tape rental
or sale records") (enacted in wake of Justice Thomas's
nomination).
Title:
CAPPS II - history and policy analysis
Description:
For the past three years, the Department of Homeland Security
(DHS) has been planning to launch a new airline passenger
screening system. In July 2004, DHS announced that it was
canceling the planned deployment for this year and going back
to the drawing board. Why did this happen? Did political
pressure from privacy advocates kill this project? Will it
come back in another form? What should DHS do in this area?
Are there better technical or policy options that DHS should
consider?
Bibliography:
CAPPS II Privacy Act notices: 68 Fed. Reg. 2101 (Jan. 15, 2003)
(original), 68 Fed. Reg. 45,265 (Aug. 1, 2003) (revised).
EFF Web page on CAPPS II: http://www.eff.org/Privacy/cappsii/
GAO report: "AVIATION SECURITY: Computer-Assisted Passenger
Prescreening System Faces Significant Implementation Challenges,"
GAO-04-385 (Feb. 12, 2004).
The 9/11 Commission Report, http://www.9-11commission.gov/
Samidh Chakrabarti and Aaron Strauss, "Carnival Booth: An
Algorithm for Defeating the Computer-Assisted Passenger
Screening System," (May 16, 2002) (6.805 student paper)
Brian Loux, "Paper Shows Airline Profiling Ineffective,"
The Tech, Oct. 18, 2002
EPIC FOIA documents on "No-Fly" watchlist,
http://www.epic.org/privacy/airtravel/foia/watchlist_foia_analysis.html
Alan Gathright, "No-fly list ensnares innocent travelers,"
S.F. Chronicle, June 8, 2003
Title:
MBTA Smart Card Implementation
Description:
In February 2003, the Massachusetts Bay Transportation
Authority awarded a contract to Scheidt & Bachmann of Germany
to replace the T's automated fare collection system. In the
summer of 2004, MBTA staff met with the staff of State
Sen. Jarrett T. Barrios. The system as designed will include
contactless smart cards (similar to MIT's proximity cards)
that store money and are linked to individual identities. The
MBTA also plans to license use of the system and the smart
cards to other businesses and libraries for their own
identification and purchasing purposes. The MBTA staff
explained that when a rider loses a smart card, they need to
be able to give them a replacement smart card with the correct
amount of money on it. Therefore, the MBTA needs to track and
save all transactions with the smart card. The system as
designed appears to keep these records indefinitely.
Sen. Barrios's staff is unsatisfied with the level of privacy
in the current design and believe that it is possible to
improve the system. They are also worried about the prospect
that unauthorized individuals may be able to read others'
smart cards remotely and even modify the amount of money, or
the identity, on them without needing physical possession of
the card.
Meet with Sen. Barrios's staff in early September and discuss
their desires and requirements. Understand the MBTA design as
much as possible. Then, come up with a technical discussion
and analysis, with recommendations for improvement and
analysis of weaknesses. You may be able to meet with the MBTA
staff in October or November.
Bibliography:
"Issue/Project Briefing: Automated Fare Collection (AFC) -
Implementing Smart Cards," MBTA document, Summer 2004
MIFARE Contactless smart cards,
http://www.semiconductors.philips.com/markets/identification/products/mifare/
Scheidt & Bachmann Web pages:
http://www.scheidt-bachmann.de/system/prod3/prod3a-e.htm
http://www.scheidt-bachmann.de/index-e.html
Title:
National ID System
Description:
Design a nationwide "smart card" system to support identity and
electronic financial transactions.
Establish design goals for the system. What should the system
do? What advantages would it yield over today's world? Should
financial transactions be completely untraceable? Should they
be tracable by authorized law enforcement agencies? Who should
be able to verify your identity, and when? Can this system be
used for elections and voting? Justify your goals as
appropriate in today's world. Are the "National ID" opponents'
fears justified?
Design and describe a technical system to meet your design goals. Who
can do what? How are the rules enforced? What safeguards are in place?
Analyze your system. What can go wrong? What are the pros and cons of
the design you chose? What are the pros and cons of the goals you
established?
Bibliography:
Alan M. Dershowitz, "Thinking About National ID Cards,"
Journal of Homeland Security, May 2002
(http://www.homelandsecurity.org/journal/articles/dershowitz2.htm)
Rick Stengel, "The Case for a National ID Card,"
Time Magazine, Oct, 17, 2001
EPIC information on National ID cards:
http://www.epic.org/privacy/id_cards/
EFF page on "National Identification Systems":
http://www.eff.org/Privacy/Surveillance/nationalidsystem.html
David Chaum, "Blind Signatures for Untraceable Payments,"
Crypto 1982
Dennis Kugler, "Auditable Tracing with Unconditional Anonymity,"
WISA 2001
eCash papers:
http://www.tcs.hut.fi/~helger/crypto/link/protocols/ecash.html
Title:
MIT ID card - privacy and security
Description:
MIT students have been issued "MIT ID" cards with magnetic
stripes for ten years. But the privacy and security issues
have never quite been resolved. What data should be collected,
who should be able to access it, and how long should it be
saved? What happened to the MIT Card Steering Committee and
the MIT Privacy Committee, and should they be reconstituted?
When data collection policies are changed, who should have a
stake in the decision, and who should be informed of changes?
What kind of privacy policy do the dormitories want, do
laboratories want, and do the MIT police want? MIT continues
to upgrade the system, e.g., adding radio "proximity" cards
last year. What improvements should MIT seek to make in the
future?
Work with disparate groups on campus (MIT Card Office,
TechCASH, MIT Police, privacy advocates, lab directors, MIT's
technical contractors) to formulate a report, including
recommended policies and the areas of privacy and security.
When MIT deploys the "next" ID system, what should it be?
Bibliography:
Andre DeHon's Web page on the MIT card, circa 1995:
http://www.ai.mit.edu/people/andre/mit_card/
CSAIL Prox Card Privacy Committee: http://proxcard.csail.mit.edu/
Vulnerabilities in the MIT Prox Card:
http://web.mit.edu/keithw/Public/MIT-Card-Vulnerabilities-March31.pdf
6.033 Spring 2000 assignment: "A 'Smart' and Secure MIT Card":
http://web.mit.edu/6.033/2000/www/handouts/h25-dp2.html
6.033 paper on "A 'Smart' and Secure MIT Card":
http://web.mit.edu/6.033/2000/www/reports/dp2-thies