Massachusetts Institute of Technology
MIT 6.805/6.806/STS085: Ethics and Law on the Electronic Frontier
Fall 2004
Guidelines and expectations for term papers (Continued)
Here are some additional notes that expand upon the general expectations for papers:
- When you turn in the half draft that is due December 2, make
sure to include pieces of writing by all of the people in the team.
Each person should turn in half what they expect to write in the final
paper.
- Also, for the Dec. 2 milestone, turn in the paper in the format
(HTML, doc, etc.) that you will use for final paper. Note that PDF is
not an accaptable format.
- A good paper makes a clear contribution and states a clear
thesis. One of our grading criteria will be to see whether a reader
who has read just the very beginning of the paper (e.g., the first two
paragraphs) can understand what the contrubtion of the paper is.
- A good paper is coherent, and fits together. It's not just a
gluing together of the four or five separate pieces of writing by the
people on the team. In making things fit together, the job of the
editor is crucial. Get the entire team together, with your outline,
and look for places that are repetitive (or contradictory!) and iron
this out. The different sections are all parts of the argument that
supports the thesis, so they should build on each other and refer to
each other.
- Good papers use primary sources. They don't just glom together
stuff you've read on the Internet. Primary sources are people you've
talked with, original documents as opposed to comments on the
documents, and original research and analysis that you've done. If
you have some good original sources, you should emphasize that in your
paper, so that it will be obvious to readers (e.g. the 6.805 staff who
will be grading your work).
- Make sure you do thorough research. At a minimum, you should
do several Lexis searches under "legal research" (you can access Lexis
Academic Universe through the MIT Library VERA gateway). For the
topics you are working on, you should be able to find dozens of law
review and journal articles. Take advantage of that. When the staff
grades papers, we'll be looking at the quality of your research and
noting how your references stack up against what we ourselves can find
with a few minutes of research.
- We'd like to be able to include these papers in the class web
archive anda lso post them on MIT OpenCourseWare, under a Creative
Commons license. If you would like us
to do that, we need a note giving permission on behalf of all
of the paper's authors. Whether or not you give permission will
have absolutely no bearing on your grade on the paper or your grade
in the course.