Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Fall Semester, 2004

MIT 6.805/6.806/STS085: Ethics and Law on the Electronic Frontier

Preparation for week of Nov. 1

This week we're back to our normal schedule of Tuesday at Harvard, Thursday at MIT.

Don't forget that your first milestone on the paper is due this week.

This week at Harvard

The Harvard class this week will be about online politics and electronic voting. mostly skim them. Check out the Digital Democracy 2004 site on the rotisserie for the syllabus and readings.

This week at MIT.

Today's class will be a presentation by the MIT ID Card team. Please read the following articles and papers, based on which group you are in. We will have some breakout discussion time that will be heavily reading focused, and then we will regroup for a class discussion. We have tried to assign a manageable amount of reading, so please come prepared.

Everyone read:

  1. MIT Card Office Privacy Policy
    http://web.mit.edu/mitcard/privacy.html>http://web.mit.edu/mitcard/privacy.html

Group 1 -- CAPPS II & Sensors in Public Spaces -- read:

  1. Old MIT Tech articles, and privacy considerations that arose in the past

    1. Shang-Ling Chuang: Card Keys Sometimes a Problem (Nov. 1994)
      This article is about some of the problems and advantages of the new card keys
      http://www-tech.mit.edu/V114/N57/keys.57n.html

    2. Ifung Lu: Card convenience, security examined (Feb. 1996)
      This article is about all the privacy concerns that arose when certain services were added the card. These are services that we have all come to love and expect from the MIT ID. These include Dominos delivery, paying for copies at copy tech, access to dorms, etc.
      http://www-tech.mit.edu/V115/N68/mitcard.100n.html

    3. Lauren LeBon: Card Entries to Campus Buildings, Labs Tracked (Jan. 2003)
      This article is about the start of entry tracking with MIT RFID card.
      http://www-tech.mit.edu/V122/N66/66card.66n.html

  2. Josh Mandel, Austin Roach, Keith Winstein: MIT Proximity Card Vulnerabilities
    http://web.mit.edu/keithw/Public/MIT-Card-Vulnerabilities-March31.pdf

Group 2 -- National ID & MBTA Smart Card -- read:

  1. Alternative designs and alternative systems

    1. Stanford: Their system has many parallels to the MIT ID card system
      1. Overview
        http://www.stanford.edu/dept/itss/services/campuscard/

      2. Security and confidentiality
        http://www.stanford.edu/dept/itss/services/campuscard/security.html

      3. Also, poke around the rest of the site to find other interesting similarities and differences to the MIT system.

    2. BU
      1. Brian Fitzgerald: A newer, smarter ID (Feb. 1998)
        This is an article from BU's Newspaper about a pilot program for a smart card id system
        http://www.bu.edu/bridge/archive/1998/02-20/features1.html

    3. Samidh Chakrabarti, James Knight, Bill Thies: A Centralized Smart Card System Utilizing Distributed Proxies
      This is a design for an alternative system to the magnetic stripe, done as a 6.033 design project in spring 2000. Read the whole report, except for section 3, which can be skimmed.
      http://web.mit.edu/6.033/2000/www/reports/dp2-thies

      (OPTIONAL) For a description of the design project assignment, go here:
      http://web.mit.edu/6.033/2000/www/handouts/h25-dp2.html