Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Fall Semester, 2004

MIT 6.805/6.806/STS085: Ethics and Law on the Electronic Frontier

Preparation for week of October 25

Both classes at MIT this week

There is no class at Harvard this week. Both the Tuesday and Thursday classes will meet at MIT. Tuesday's class will meet at in the Stata Center in room 32-D463. Thurday's class will meet in the usual room.

To find the classroom in the Stata Center (bldg 32): Go to the 4th floor of building 36, then through the door at the end of the corridor that leads into the 4th floor of the Stata Center. Walk down the corridor and you should find room D463 to your right, just before the large area that opens onto an outside patio ot the right. Feel free to explore alternate routes.

Guidelines and expectations for term papers

Please read the guidelines and expectations for term papers. As you'll see, there is a sequence of milestones, starting with a statement of a thesis due next week.

Tuesday, Oct. 26 at MIT

Today's class will be a presentation by the MBTA team. State Senator Jarrett Barrios will be our guest. For preparation, please read:

  1. (Optional) RFID Privacy Law, Part 1, Sections C - F (6 pages)
    This reading provides strong background on RFID technology and the numerous privacy concerns surrounding its implementation. It also covers arguments from both advocates and opponents of RFID technology and current legal activity. Anyone without background in the RFID subject should tackle this light reading first.
    http://www.stanford.edu/~hsurden/RFID_Privacy_Law.htm

  2. MBTA Action Plan to Senator Barrios (4 pages)
    Senator Barrios requested information from the MBTA regarding their progress on a privacy policy. They responded with a personal memo and the attached action plan outlining their manner of addressing these privacy concerns, as well as a general introduction to the smart card idea.
    PDF file here

  3. Gilmore v. Ashcroft, Brief of Amicus Curiae in Support of Appellant (20 pages)
    This reading considers the Constitutional right to travel freely and anonymously in light of the ongoing case Gilmore v. Ashcroft in the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals. You read the Appellee's brief last week.
    http://209.123.170.170/gilmore/_dl/CCR&PA%20Amicus%20Brief.pdf

  4. RFID tags become hacker target (1 page)
    Security concerns with RFID technology and the read/write capabilities available to the general public. It documents a product that can rewrite the contents of an RFID card.
    http://news.com.com/RFID+tags+become+hacker+target/2100-1029_3-5287912.html

  5. Philips Article about MiCard (3 pages)
    Technological overview of the RFID technology embedded in the proposed MBTA Smart Cards.
    http://www.semiconductors.philips.com/markets/identification/articles/articles/a34/

  6. (Optional) Smart Card Alliance: Privacy and Secure Identification (26 pages)
    White paper written in 2003 by a multi-industry alliance promoting the use of Smart Cards, and a demonstration of their approach to integrating privacy protections. Observe the differences between this approach to privacy and those taken by civil society organizations.
    PDF file here

  7. (Optional) Michel Foucalt: Excerpt from "Panopticism" from Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison
    Begin reading at the paragraph that begins "Bentham's Panopticon is the architectural figure," and end the section at the phrase "through and through with disciplinary mechanisms." The entire section runs about 9 pages, and outlines a theory of surveillance and power as exercized in modern, rational societies.
    http://foucault.info/documents/disciplineAndPunish/foucault.disciplineAndPunish.panOpticism.html

Thursday, Oct. 28 at MIT

Today's class will be a presentation by the National Identity Card team. For preparation, please read:

  1. Alan Dershowitz, Thinking About National ID Cards
    This is an article by Harvard Law School professor Alan Dershowitz on why he supports the National ID card which covers some of the issues raised by opponents of a National ID as well. (About 2 pages)
    http://www.homelanddefense.org/journal/articles/dershowitz2.htm

  2. Bob Sullivan, A safer America: The document problem
    This is an MSNBC article which succinctly describes one of the major reasons for why a strong national ID system is desired and also presents some of the opposition to such IDs. (About 6 pages)
    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/5946145/

  3. Richard Sobel, The degrdation of political identity under a national identification system
    This article, published in the Boston University Journal of Science and Technology Law presents a detailed analysis by a Senior Research Associate at Harvard University of some concerns and sources of opposition to a national ID system. (15 pages of reading, 17 pages of footnotes)
    http://web.mit.edu/sentry/www/political_identity.pdf

  4. AS Sertifitseerimiskeskus, The Estonian ID card and digital signature concept
    Many other countries have implemented smart card national ID systems. One of the more recent and fairly advanced is that which was just recently implemented by the country of Estonia. This paper is a lucid description of the system and policies surrounding it. (16 pages)
    http://www.id.ee/file.php?id=122

  5. Experience of Using Smart Identity Cards in Other Countries
    The Hong Kong Panel on Security of the Legislative Council held a meeting in November of 2000 to discuss the implementation of a national smart identity card. Some members of the board wanted information on the experience of other countries in implementing such systems. This document outlines the uses of smart identity cards in several countries and provides a comparison chart for how smart ID cards are being used in many other countries. (10 pages)
    http://www.legco.gov.hk/yr00-01/english/panels/se/papers/b695e01.pdf

  6. David Chaum, Blind signatures for untraceable payments
    (Optional) Blind signatures form the basis for most cryptographic mechanisms discussed for voting and payment applications. This is the original paper that introduced the concept and provides a real-world analogy for the mathematics behind it. (5 pages)
    http://web.mit.edu/sentry/www/blind_signatures.pdf