Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Fall Semester, 2004

MIT 6.805/6.806/STS085: Ethics and Law on the Electronic Frontier

Preparation for week of October 18

This week at Harvard

The Harvard class this week will be a negotiation exercise on Voice Over IP. There are a bunch of readings to do for this, but you can mostly skim them. Check out the Digital Democracy 2004 site on the rotisserie for the syllabus and readings. There's also a writing assignment due on Voice Over IP.

Remember also that you're supposed to download Skype and install it and play with it. We deliberately aren't giving you more information than this, partly to get you to think about how "consumer friendly" this is.

This week at MIT

Today's class will be a presentation by the CAPPS II team. As preparation, please read:

  1. CAPPS II System of Records notice: Document filed by the Transportation Security Authority in compliance with the Privacy Act of 1974, which explains the system of records they intended to create to facilitate the CAPPS II system. Pay careful attention to the nature of information being stored, and the (admittedly vague) picture of what they intended to do with it. http://www.dhs.gov/interweb/assetlibrary/CAPPSII_PRIVACY_ACT_NOTICE.pdf

  2. Secure Flight Test Records System of Records notice The same sort of document, filed to explain the system of records being created as part of the testing phase for the CAPPS II replacement program Secure Flight. Here, pay attention to what's different (other than the fact that this notice is for a testing phase of the program in question) from CAPPS II, and what hasn't changed at all. http://www.tsa.gov/public/interweb/assetlibrary/Secure_Flight_SORN_9.21.04.pdf

  3. Congressional Briefing on CAPPS II Dated March 7th of last year - this is an attempt by the backers of CAPPS II to dispel some of the misinformation that had been floating around surrounding the CAPPS II system. It containts a very clearly stated list of the problems with the CAPPS system and the goals of its successor. http://www.acte.org/initiatives/CAPPS_II_CongressBriefing.pdf

  4. The Seven Problems With CAPPS II An ACLU article subtitled "Why the Airline Passenger Profiling Proposal Should Be Abandoned." It's a good summary of the key civil liberties issues surrounding the deployment of a passenger pre-screening program. It's a decent summary of the positions of most CAPPS II opposition. http://www.aclu.org/Privacy/Privacy.cfm?ID=15426&c=130

  5. Secure Flight Gets Wary Welcome A short article from Wired Magazine announcing the arrival of Secure Flight onto the scene at the end of August of this year. It serves as a reasonable summary of what has happened up to this point and is a pretty quick read. http://www.wired.com/news/privacy/0,1848,64748,00.html?tw=wn_1polihead

  6. (Optional - please skim) Defendant John Ashcroft, et. al. Reply Brief This is a fairly long brief filed by John Ashcroft on 29 September in the case of Gilmore v. Ashcroft. The case fundamentally involves the question of whether the government can constitutionally demand ID for travellers. You should at least familiarize yourself with the procedural history, however Ashcroft's arguments are quite thorough and provide a great deal of insight into the questions at hand so it's worth looking over.

    http://209.123.170.170/gilmore/_dl/DOJ%20opo%20brief.pdf

    In fact, if you have some time to kill it's worth browsing around the web site which has been set up to follow this case:

    http://www.papersplease.org/gilmore/legal.html

    particularly since the brief mentioned above does not (for obvious reasons) really focus on Mr. Gilmore's complaints. It's a very nicely put together site. Again, pay attention to the procedural history at least, as we intend to discuss some of the proceedings in our presentation.